The Chronicle of Philanthropy published a piece this week about the high cost of low nonprofit pay.
It wasn’t controversial.
It was honest.
The article highlighted something many of us in the field have known for years:
- Roughly 1 in 5 nonprofit workers fall into the ALICE category (Asset-Limited, Income-Constrained, Employed).
- Staff are routinely doing 60 hours of work while being paid for 40.
- Turnover is high.
- Continuity is fragile.
- Leadership pipelines are thinning.
None of that surprised me.
What continues to surprise me is that we still act like this has nothing to do with fundraising performance.
It has everything to do with it.
We Don’t Have a Motivation Problem. We Have a Structure Problem.
For more than two decades, I’ve watched well-intentioned nonprofits try to solve structural problems with heroic hires.
One Development Director.
Expected to manage:
- Major gifts
- Annual fund
- Grants
- Events
- Social media
- Newsletter
- CRM cleanup
- Board engagement
- Stewardship strategy
All while “building a culture of philanthropy.”
It’s not that these professionals lack talent.
It’s that we’ve designed a job no one can sustainably do.
Hiring one person to be your entire development department is like hiring your plumber to build your house.
Eventually, something breaks.
Usually, it’s the person.
And when they leave (often within 12–18 months), the organization resets to zero:
- Donor relationships stall
- Data integrity erodes
- Institutional knowledge walks out the door
- Boards grow frustrated
- Staff morale dips
And then we repeat the cycle.
No Database, No Donor Development.
Fundraising is not magic.
It is infrastructure.
It is systems.
It is disciplined data.
It is a shared responsibility.
You cannot build sustainable donor relationships without clean, structured data and team-based accountability.
And you cannot expect one underpaid professional to shoulder the emotional and operational weight of an entire revenue engine.
Development is a team sport.
We keep trying to run it like a solo marathon.
The Real Cost
Low pay doesn’t just hurt employees.
It destabilizes mission delivery.
It weakens fundraising capacity.
It creates a hidden operational tax that organizations quietly absorb in the form of turnover, burnout, and lost momentum.
The Chronicle article challenges nonprofits and funders to rethink the math.
I would add this:
We also need to rethink the structure.
Sustainable fundraising doesn’t come from heroics.
It comes from realistic workload design. From shared capacity. From investing in infrastructure before expecting exponential revenue.
The sector is finally naming the compensation problem.
The next step is naming the structural one.
Because until we do, we will keep hiring unicorns — and wondering why they disappear.
If you have questions, reach us through 📧 [email protected]
🗓️ Schedule time: https://meetings.hubspot.com/eddie94