If you’ve spent time in the nonprofit sector, you’ve seen it: a job posting that asks one person to be a grant writer, communications manager, donor development officer, event planner, and sponsorship closer — all at once.
On paper, it looks efficient. In practice, it’s a recipe for burnout and turnover.
Why Unicorn Roles Fail
- Grant Writing ≠ Communications. Grant writing is research-driven, technical, and compliance-heavy. Communications is creative, outward-facing, and brand-driven. Expecting one person to excel at both is like asking your plumber to design your house.
- Unrealistic Expectations. Boards often think in headcount: “We can only afford one more staffer, so let’s combine everything.” The result? A bloated job description that no single human can sustain.
High Turnover Costs. The average Development Director lasts less than 16 months. Replacing them costs nonprofits upwards of $130,000 in salary, benefits, and recruitment. Each failed hire stalls donor relationships and drains organizational momentum.
A Better Path Forward
At Pacific Northwest Fundraising (PNWF), we see this every day — and we’ve built a model that solves it:
- Deliver the expertise of a whole development department — grant writers, principal gift officers, event planners, communications managers — under one fractional contract.
- Eliminate costly turnover and HR overhead by engaging a team of specialists for less than the cost of one full-time hire.
Build sustainable fundraising infrastructure first, then secure capacity-building grants to fund permanent hires when the timing is right.
The Takeaway
Nonprofits don’t need unicorns. They need systems, specialists, and sustainability.
Every time a nonprofit tries to combine multiple disciplines into one role, it gambles with staff burnout, donor engagement, and long-term stability. PNWF exists to end that cycle and put the right people in the right seats from the start.
Let’s discuss whether your nonprofit struggles with the “unicorn role” trap.
[email protected] | Book a call https://meetings.hubspot.com/eddie94